Dolphins Earn First Win but Lose Tyreek Hill to Devastating Injury

The Miami Dolphins finally broke into the win column on Monday night, but the celebration was muted. A 27-21 victory over the rival New York Jets gave Miami its first triumph of the 2025 season, yet the night will be remembered for a frightening injury to star wide receiver Tyreek Hill. The explosive playmaker dislocated his left knee early in the third quarter, was carted off the field with an air cast, and later taken to a nearby hospital for further evaluation. Initial reports confirmed ligament damage and a season-ending prognosis, casting doubt on his future with the team.
For Miami, the win itself was a grind. Quarterback Tua Tagovailoa managed the game efficiently, completing 17 of 25 passes for 177 yards and two touchdowns, while avoiding the costly turnovers that had plagued him through the first three weeks. Darren Waller, in his long-awaited return to NFL action, provided an unexpected spark, catching three passes including two for touchdowns. Running back De’Von Achane added balance with 99 rushing yards and a score, giving Miami just enough offensive push after Hill’s departure stalled the passing attack.
Defensively, the Dolphins survived by creating takeaways. Three Jets fumbles — from Justin Fields, Braelon Allen, and Isaiah Williams — flipped momentum and set up 14 Miami points. Cornerback Jack Jones produced perhaps the play of the night when he stripped Allen at the goal line in the first quarter, preventing an early New York touchdown. Minkah Fitzpatrick and the rest of the secondary played opportunistic football, while linebacker Jordyn Brooks racked up 18 tackles in a heroic performance. Still, the Dolphins were gashed for 197 rushing yards, with Fields and Breece Hall repeatedly breaking containment.
For the Jets, the story was all too familiar: flashes of talent undone by mistakes and lack of discipline. Fields, returning from a concussion, led New York with 81 rushing yards and connected with Garrett Wilson on a spectacular late touchdown, but three turnovers and 13 penalties totaling 101 yards buried any chance at a comeback. At 0-4, Aaron Glenn’s squad looks far from competitive, and their reliance on Fields’ improvisation underscores a one-dimensional offense still searching for an identity.
The Dolphins improved to 1-3, but the win comes at enormous cost. Hill, who caught six passes for 67 yards before the injury, has been Miami’s offensive centerpiece since arriving in 2022, his speed and production redefining the unit. Now, with his season over and his contract carrying a massive 2026 cap hit, his future with the franchise is uncertain. Coach Mike McDaniel will be forced to lean on Waller, Jaylen Waddle, and creative personnel groupings to keep the offense afloat.
Tagovailoa’s perfect record against the Jets — now 6-0 — remains intact, but the Dolphins face daunting questions moving forward. Their defense remains vulnerable on the ground, their offensive line still banged up, and their most dynamic weapon may never again wear aqua and orange. What should have been a night of relief instead left Miami with a victory that feels hollow, a Pyrrhic triumph that may reshape the course of their season.

Check out LifeWalletSports.com to get connected with all of our NIL athletes and partnered brands